All posts
Guides

Open Enrollment Is a Plan Decision. Size Your FSA From What You Actually Spent.

November 3, 2026by The DollarAMP Team

For plan years beginning in 2026, the IRS caps health FSA salary reductions at $3,400. Carryover is optional for employers. If yours allows it, at most $680 of unused money from a 2026 plan year can roll into the next one, and your employer can set a lower cap (Rev. Proc. 2025-32, section 4.15). Elect more than you spend, and the rest can be forfeited. The IRS has not yet published the 2027 health FSA limit, so check your employer's enrollment materials for the final number.

Open enrollment asks you to guess a year of medical spending on one form. You do not have to guess. If you have kept a plan for a year, you already have the record.

The election is a sinking fund you fund in advance

A health FSA works backwards from a normal sinking fund. You choose the total up front, and it comes out of each paycheck before the deposit lands. Two rules from IRS Publication 969 shape the math:

  • The full election is available early. Your employer's FSA must let you be reimbursed up to the amount you elected at any time during the coverage period, regardless of how much you have contributed so far.
  • Unused money is generally lost. FSAs are "use-it-or-lose-it." An employer can offer either a grace period of up to 2 1/2 months after the plan year ends or a carryover, but not both, and it doesn't have to offer either.

So the risk is lopsided. Elect too little and you pay the rest from take-home pay, as you do now. Elect too much and the excess can disappear. Elect close to spending you are confident will happen.

Pull the number from your plan

In YNAB, look at spending in the categories that cover FSA-eligible costs: copays, prescriptions, dental, vision, the deductible. Use the last twelve months.

Then sort that spending into two piles:

  1. Recurring and predictable. Monthly prescriptions, scheduled dental cleanings, glasses or contacts on a regular cycle, therapy copays.
  2. One-time. The urgent care visit, the emergency crown, the procedure you already finished.

The first pile is your floor. Elect at least that, because you know it is coming. Add one-time costs only if you already know about them for next year, like a planned procedure or new glasses. Leave the surprises to your cash categories, where an unused dollar stays yours.

Do the per-paycheck arithmetic before you click submit

Example math: Divide the election by your pay periods. A $1,200 election paid biweekly is 26 deductions of about $46.15 each. On a semimonthly schedule, it is 24 deductions of $50. Use your own election and pay schedule.

Your January deposit shrinks by a little less than that, because the deduction comes out before federal income and payroll taxes. Two plan changes follow:

  • Income drops. Your plan only sees what lands in checking, so the paycheck you plan with gets smaller. Update any scheduled income transactions for the new amount when the first January paycheck arrives.
  • The medical category needs less from take-home pay. Eligible costs now come out of the FSA, so the category only has to cover what the FSA will not: ineligible items, anything over your election, and the timing gap if you pay first and wait for reimbursement.

If you pay first and submit claims, the reimbursement arrives later as a separate deposit. Record it when it lands and give those dollars a job then.

If you are choosing a high-deductible plan with an HSA instead

An HSA follows different rules: the balance stays yours from year to year, so there is no forfeiture problem to size around. For calendar year 2027, the IRS sets the contribution limit at $4,500 for self-only coverage and $9,000 for family coverage, and a qualifying high-deductible plan needs a deductible of at least $1,750 self-only or $3,500 family (Rev. Proc. 2026-24).

Use the last two months of this year

Check your current FSA balance against your FSA's year-end rule. If you hold more than the carryover allows and have no grace period, pay December's eligible costs, like a refill or new glasses, from the FSA instead of your medical category. Those category dollars are then free for other work.

January can stack a smaller paycheck, a deductible that resets on most calendar-year plans, and annual bills into one tight month. A forward view of your scheduled transactions, like DollarAMP's cash-flow calendar, which projects your balance day by day up to 90 days out, shows that week before it arrives. The math works on paper too.

The takeaway: open the last twelve months of your medical categories, total the recurring costs plus any one-time costs you already know are coming, and elect that. Divide it by your pay periods so January's smaller paycheck is already in your plan.

Your plan, a month ahead.

DollarAMP reads the plan you already keep in YNAB and shows you what it turns into.